Part 2: My 7-Year-Old Daughter Hid in a Closet Every Night Her Father Came Home Drunk — Our Golden Retriever Started Going in With Her, and One Night He Did Something I Will Never Be Able to Repay
The first time I noticed Sunday was missing from the kitchen on a bad night, I assumed he was sleeping somewhere upstairs.
The second time, I assumed the same thing.
The third time, I went looking for him.
I tiptoed up the carpeted stairs after Ronnie had passed out in front of the television. I checked Lily’s room. I opened her door very softly. The bed was empty.
I looked at the closet.
The closet was closed.
I knelt down and put my ear against the louvered door.
I heard Lily breathing.
And I heard, underneath her breathing, a second, slower breathing.
I opened the closet door three inches.
Sunday lifted his head off the floor. He was lying on his side, lengthwise along the back wall of the closet. His big golden body was pressed against Lily’s small flannel-pajama-clad back. Her hands were in his fur. Her cheek was against his shoulder. She was asleep. She was asleep in a closet at 11:30 p.m., on the floor, holding a Golden Retriever who had walked himself in there without being asked.
Sunday looked at me.
He did not get up.
He did not wag his tail.
He looked at me with the expression of a creature who was on duty and was politely asking me not to interrupt.
I closed the door.
I went back downstairs.
I sat on the kitchen floor with my back against the dishwasher for two hours and tried to figure out what kind of woman I had become.
This kept happening.
Every night Ronnie’s truck came up the driveway after midnight, Sunday would go upstairs. He would push Lily’s bedroom door open with his nose. He would walk into the closet — Lily had figured out, by then, to leave it cracked for him — and he would lie down between her body and the closet door.
He never barked.
He never whined.
He never made a sound. Not once. Not in months.
He was eight years old, sixty-five pounds, and he understood, the way Border Collies understand sheep, that his job was to be quiet and to be present and to be between.
I knew this and I did not stop it.
I knew this and I did not call anyone.
I had been told, three different times, by Ronnie, what would happen if I called anyone. I believed him each time. I had no money in my own name. I had no family within six hundred miles. I had a daughter and a dog and a job and a husband who could be charming on a Sunday afternoon at his mother’s house.
I was thirty-three years old and I had stopped being a person.
Sunday had not stopped being a person.
I will get to that.
It was the second weekend of April.
Ronnie had been drinking at a friend’s house since two in the afternoon. He came home at 12:14 a.m.
I heard the truck. I heard the door. I heard him miss the second step on the porch. I heard him swear.
I was sitting on the kitchen floor with my back against the cabinets where I had been sitting for an hour because I had not been able to make myself go to bed.
He came in.
He walked past me.
He went upstairs.
I did not understand what was happening fast enough.
By the time I was on my feet, by the time I was at the bottom of the stairs, by the time my hand was on the railing — he was already at the top of the stairs, in front of Lily’s room, opening the closet door.
I will tell you what happened in the next ninety seconds, because it is what made everything afterward possible. I will tell it to you the way Lily told it to me, three days later, on a couch in a women’s shelter in Joplin.
Lily said, “Daddy opened the door.”
She said, “Sunday stood up.”
She said, “Sunday made a sound I have never heard him make.”
She said, “Sunday got in front of me.”
She said, “Sunday did not move.”
She said, “Daddy was loud.”
She said, “Daddy kicked Sunday three times.”
She said, “Sunday did not move.”
She said, “Sunday did not make a sound after the first one.”
She said, “Daddy left.”
I came up the stairs. I came in the room. I came to the closet.
Lily was sitting on the floor of the closet with both arms around the dog.
The dog was standing.
He was standing between her and the open closet door.
He was breathing in a way that was wrong. There was a small smear of blood on the carpet from a tooth that had cut into his lip when his head went sideways.
He was looking at me.
He was still on duty.
I knelt down on the closet floor in my flannel pajamas and I said, “Sunday. It’s okay. I’ve got her.”
He let me put my arms around Lily. He took one step backwards. He sat down on the carpet outside the closet.
He watched me lift my daughter off the floor.
He walked, slowly, behind us as I carried her down the hall.
He did not stop watching the stairs.
I want to tell you what I did the next morning, because for three years I had not done it.
Ronnie was passed out in our bed at 7:14 a.m.
Lily was in our guest room with Sunday pressed against her side.
I went down to the kitchen.
I sat at the table.
I looked at the dog through the open guest room door at the top of the stairs.
He was asleep. He had finally allowed himself to sleep. His side was rising and falling slowly. There was a dark patch of hair on his ribs where he had been kicked. His chin was on Lily’s pillow.
He had stood between my daughter and her father for three kicks and he had not run.
I thought about the last three years.
I thought about every time Ronnie had told me what would happen if I called.
I thought about every time I had believed him.
I thought about the fact that an eight-year-old Golden Retriever — sixty-five pounds, not aggressive, not a guard dog, not trained for any of this — had been braver than I had been for thirty-six months in the space of one night.
I picked up the phone.
I called the non-emergency line for the Greene County sheriff’s office.
I told them, in a voice that did not sound like mine, what had been happening in my house.
A deputy was at our front door in twenty-two minutes.
By 11 a.m., Ronnie was in the back of a county vehicle. Lily and I were in another car, with a victim’s advocate, on our way to a women’s shelter in Joplin that took dogs.
Sunday rode in the backseat with Lily.
He kept his head on her lap the entire way.
A woman at the shelter named Patricia — she had run the place for nineteen years — sat with me in the family room on the first night.
She made me tea.
She watched Sunday lying on the linoleum floor with Lily curled against his stomach watching cartoons.
She said, “Honey. How long have you been wanting to leave?”
I said, “A long time.”
She said, “What changed last night?”
I told her about Sunday.
I told her about the closet.
I told her about the kicks.
I told her about how he had stood there and not moved.
I said, “Patricia. I have been less brave than my dog.”
Patricia was quiet for a long time.
Then she said, “Honey. A lot of women in this house got out because of a dog. I’m gonna tell you something I tell every single one of them. Your dog didn’t shame you out. Your dog showed you what was possible. There’s a difference.”
She said, “He didn’t have to be braver than you. He just had to go first.”
She said, “You went second.”
She said, “That’s how it works.”
I cried at her kitchen table for about half an hour.
She sat with me. She did not hand me tissues. She did not pat my back. She just sat across from me and waited.
When I was done, she said, “Sweetheart. Now we work.”
We have been out for fourteen months now.
Lily is eight. She is in a third-grade class at a small elementary school in a town I am not going to name. She has a friend named Maya. She has a teacher who told me, at a parent conference in October, “Mrs. — ” (and she used my new last name, my maiden name, the name I have taken back) — “Lily is one of the brightest kids in my class. I just want you to know that.”
I work at a community college now. Front desk. Health benefits. My own paycheck.
Sunday is nine.
He is gray almost all the way up his face. His left hip — the one Ronnie kicked — is stiff in cold weather. The vet says he probably has another two or three good years.
He sleeps at the foot of Lily’s bed every night.
The closet door is always open. We have not closed it once since we moved.
Lily has not slept inside it.
She has, on three separate occasions, sat on the floor of her closet at bedtime to read a book to Sunday — who lies on the carpet just outside the door and listens. Last week the book was Ramona and Her Father.
I stood in the hallway and listened to her read for ten minutes.
I did not go in.
I did not interrupt.
I went back to the kitchen and stood at the sink and let the water run.
Last month at the dog park, a woman with a young Lab asked me about Sunday.
She said, “Is he yours?”
I said, “Yes, ma’am.”
She said, “He’s beautiful. How long have you had him?”
I said, “Nine years.”
She said, “What did he do for you?”
I think she meant what does he do — what tricks, what jobs, what kind of dog is he.
I heard her differently.
I said, “Ma’am. He went first.”
She tilted her head.
I said, “Sorry. Long story. He’s a good dog.”
She smiled.
She said, “I can tell.”
Sunday lay down in the grass and closed his eyes in the sun.
Lily ran past with Maya.
I stood in the dog park with a person I had become and watched my daughter laugh at full volume.
He had gone first.
I had gone second.
That’s how it works.
If somebody once went first when you couldn’t — say their name below.
